Merch

25 Disney Halloween Popcorn Buckets and Sippers: Prices and Stories

By Rob 7 min read

Rob Whiteside calls this stuff "plastics," and Halloween is the category he has more of than any other, including Star Wars, Christmas, and Pixar. On a Friday night show with the chat guessing along, he walked through 25 of his Halloween popcorn buckets and sippers, one at a time, with where each came from, what it cost, and what's weird about it. The guesses in chat for his total ran from 75 to 86. The real number is closer to 32 to 35, and 25 of them made it on camera.

The Quick Take

  • 25 buckets and sippers on camera, with at least seven more at home that didn't make the show, putting the full Halloween count around 32 to 35
  • About $610 total for the 25, by Rob's own tally
  • The price climb is real: his first Halloween piece, a 2017 Oogie Boogie, cost about $15. The priciest of the 25 hit $37.99
  • Nightmare Before Christmas runs the table, with eight of the 25 tied to it
  • Chat favorites: the Headless Horseman and the Victor Giest organ sipper
  • The one he loves and can't trust: the Cusco sipper, which leaks
  • Party exclusives disappear fast. The Hatbox Ghost sold out the night Rob attended, and the vampire teddy bear sold out quickly too

A note on the numbers: prices and dates come from Rob's own notes and he flagged a few as approximate, so treat them as ballpark.

The Rules That Keep It From Getting Out of Hand

Rob will admit he's a little crazy about these, so he set rules to keep from going broke:

  • It has to come from a Disney park. One or two exceptions exist, but nothing from a movie theater and nothing off a store shelf
  • It has to come from a popcorn cart or food vendor, not a gift shop
  • It has to be a new design. A new strap on an existing mold doesn't count, which is why he skipped the new Baymax from the Animation Courtyard
  • No eBay. If he can't buy it himself or through a friend, he doesn't get it
  • Nothing goes inside. He asks for the popcorn on the side so the collectible stays clean

The Nightmare Before Christmas Crew (8)

Jack and Oogie Boogie are the closest thing Disney Halloween plastic has to a house IP, and Rob's collection shows it.

  • Oogie Boogie, full body (2017, about $15). The one that started the Halloween shelf. Dice base, bugs in the mouth, a Disney Parks strap, and it glows in the dark. That's all it does
  • Oogie Boogie head (Mickey's Not So Scary, August 2019, $18). The eyes light up, though the batteries are long dead. Rob noticed air holes in the back that wouldn't keep popcorn in very well
  • Jack Skellington seated sipper (2019 party, about $17). The most ridiculous sipper in the collection, by Rob's own ranking. The coattails lift so he can sit, the arms bend, and you sip from the back
  • Jack Skellington head (Disneyland, December 2020, $20). A simple, good-looking bucket with an annual pass strap from before Magic Keys. It takes AAA batteries and would hold plenty of popcorn
  • The Mayor's car (east coast party exclusive, $28). The Mayor's head turns as the wheels roll, Lock, Shock, and Barrel sit in back and light up, and a full popcorn bucket fits inside, so the bucket never has to get messy
  • Vampire teddy bear ($26). Big, with bendable arms and legs and a plastic cape. It sold out fast, and you reach into its mouth for the popcorn
  • Jack on a tombstone (Mickey's Not So Scary, last year, $26.29). He folds in half for no obvious reason, the pumpkin lights up, and the popcorn goes in through the side of the tombstone
  • The Mayor sipper (Mickey's Not So Scary, last year). The head spins and snaps into place, and the head and hat detach for easier travel. Rob chased this one down at Friar's Nook after Pinocchio's Village Haus turned out to be closed

Haunted Mansion (6)

  • The Hitchhiking Ghosts trio (2019 party). Phineas is the popcorn bucket ($18), Gus is a donut holder at Walt Disney World and a beignet holder at Disneyland ($12), and Ezra is the sipper ($15.99). Each was sold at a different stand, and they hook together. A great concept, and Rob admits he and his group wasted most of that party running around collecting them
  • The Haunted Mansion bride sipper ($35). Tied to the redone bride scene when the attraction reopened. It plays music, the heart beats, and the candelabra lights up, but Rob says it feels like plain plastic for the price
  • Victor Gist at the organ (Disneyland only, $34.79). The standout of the night. You play the keys to make it play music, it's slightly translucent, and it feels heavy and substantial. The chat called it the best one yet
  • The Hatbox Ghost (Disneyland and the Mickey's Not So Scary party, around $28 at the party). It makes noise, and there's a mask inside the bucket that you won't want to get popcorn on. Rob bought his in New Orleans Square the Sunday after D23 day, after arriving too late the first night and finding every popcorn cart closed

Everyone Gets a Costume (4)

  • Vampire Stitch (Disneyland, $31.90). Later sold at the party and at Disneyland Paris. Heavy, solid, with a strap covered in Stitch, candy, and bats. Popcorn goes in through the mouth
  • Stitch mummy (both coasts, $37.99 at Disneyland). The pricey end of the collection. Stitch is wrapped in toilet paper with the rolls at the base, and it lights up
  • Alien dressed as Buzz sipper (Disneyland, 2024, $21.29). Released the same day as Vampire Stitch. A button pops out the wings, not very smoothly, but he's cute. There's a jetpack version Rob hasn't picked up
  • Vampire Mickey (this year, $28). A day guest item at most parks. Rob bought it at Hollywood Studios on the way out before heading back for the party, and it has a cape, fangs, a jack-o'-lantern, and Mickey and Minnie on the strap

Cars Land (2)

  • Vampire Tomater (Disney California Adventure only, $30). A Dracula Mater with a very fragile back panel, which makes bringing it home a stress test. Rob now owns three Maters (the original, this one, and a Santa version) plus a Lightning McQueen, and hopes the coming Cars area at Magic Kingdom brings more to the east coast
  • Spooky Cone (Cozy Cone, Disneyland only, 2025, $29.79). Lights up, has a pop top and a back handle, and is only sold at the Cozy Cone

The One-Offs (5)

  • Coco skull sipper (Disney California Adventure, $24.69). Lights up, and several variants with different designs followed. Rob's rule against near-duplicates kept him to one
  • Kuzco sipper from The Emperor's New Groove (Magic Key exclusive at Disneyland, $29.79). Resellers were asking around $70 on pre-orders. It's one of his favorite designs, but the liquid sealed in the walls leaks, it's sticky to this day, and he's afraid to tilt it
  • The Headless Horseman ($30, Mickey's Not So Scary party exclusive). The pumpkin lights up and it stands on two legs. The catch: the hinge slides back instead of leaning, so it keeps popping open on him. Rob and his son each bought one
  • Mickey jack-o'-lantern sipper (both coasts, $24.99). Simple, lights up, and has Happy Halloween etched into the back
  • Ghost Mickey (2025, $36 to $37.99 depending on location). Rob passed on it at first, felt the regret, and eventually had friends grab one at each coast before it was gone

What the Collection Taught Him

  • Buy party exclusives early. The lines wrap around the hub's popcorn cart toward Cosmic Ray's, and some pieces sell out. Rob will stash purchases in a locker. At Disneyland the locker is partway down Main Street, while at Magic Kingdom you have to go all the way out past the train station
  • Disneyland pieces tend to stick around longer but cost more. Walt Disney World is often cheaper but gates more behind the party ticket
  • Resellers are a real frustration. People walk out with 20 at a time while other fans can't get one, and Rob's hope is that Disney just floods the market
  • Travel is the scary part. Straps break (the big Festival of the Arts domes were notorious for it), and flying with fragile details stresses him out. On the last trip he drove
  • Check your batteries. Several of his lights are dead, and fresh batteries would fix that
  • One caution on the Winnie the Pooh honeybee sipper: Rob didn't get one because it vanished before he could, and a viewer in the Discord said it was recalled for product defects after a few were sold at Walt Disney World. Rob said that would explain why it was gone

What Didn't Make the Show

At least seven more are still at home: the skeleton Mickey, the skeleton Pluto sipper, the Sanderson Sisters Minnie, Zero in his doghouse, the full-size Hatbox Ghost, the Donald candy corn sipper, and the Ernesto de la Cruz guitar bucket. Add those and the Halloween shelf lands in that 32 to 35 range, nowhere near the 86 the chat guessed.

Which One Wins?

The chat came down on the Headless Horseman and the Victor Gist organ sipper as the standouts, and Rob's own enthusiasm for the vampire teddy bear and the Mayor's car was easy to hear. Whichever one is yours, the invitation stood: tell him your favorite.


Watch the full episode above to see every piece up close. Catch new episodes of the Park Adventurers Club on Sunday nights, plus A Look on the Plus Side on Wednesdays and our Friday shows, on the channel. Support the channel at patreon.com/gopac.

Upcoming Live Shows

YouTube ↗
  1. Up next

    Park Adventurers Club

    with Rob Whiteside

    The parks show. Every Sunday night.

    Watch live : Park Adventurers Club on YouTube
  2. A Look on the Plus Side – Mickey: The Story of a Mouse

    with Rob Whiteside

    The review show. Every Wednesday night.

    Watch live : A Look on the Plus Side – Mickey: The Story of a Mouse on YouTube
  3. TGIF! Disney Vinyl Albums – Haul and Tell

    Watch live : TGIF! Disney Vinyl Albums – Haul and Tell on YouTube

Join the PAC

Get new posts and episode alerts in your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.